Why Dark Colors Make Your Products Appear More Powerful: A Small Business Owner’s Guide
Have you ever noticed how premium products often come in darker packaging? That’s not a coincidence! Let’s talk about a simple change that could boost your sales without changing your product at all.
Want your products to seem stronger and more effective? Go darker with your packaging.
Research shows that consumers perceive products with darker-colored packages as having a higher concentration of ingredients, leading them to judge the products as more effective. This isn’t just a theory – it’s backed by solid evidence.
In experiments with anti-hair loss shampoo, 65% of people preferred the darker version, rating it 12.3% more effective than the identical product in lighter packaging. What’s more, people were 6.9% more likely to buy personal care items with dark packaging across the board.
Why Does This Work?
Our brains make quick connections based on color. Black packaging, for example, represents “authority and luxury” and “exudes a top-tier product identity.” When we see a product in darker packaging, we automatically think:
- It’s more concentrated
- It contains stronger ingredients
- It will work better and faster
- It’s more premium and high-quality
For business products, darker blues typically convey “trustworthiness and intelligence” – which explains why many consumer electronics companies use this color scheme.
The Power/Safety Trade-Off
There’s an interesting catch to this color psychology. While dark colors make products seem more effective, they also raise concerns about possible side effects.
When consumers see darker packaging, they perceive the product as more powerful but may also worry about safety issues. This creates what’s called the “power/safety trade-off.”
When to Go Dark (And When Not To)
As a small business owner, you should consider using darker packaging when:
- Your product’s main selling point is effectiveness – If customers buy your product primarily because it works well (cleaning products, pain relievers, hair products, cosmetics), darker packaging can increase perceived value.
- You’re positioning your product as premium – Darker colors, especially black, navy, and deep burgundy, signal luxury and higher quality.
- You want to stand out in a category full of light colors – If your competitors all use white or pastel packaging, going darker creates instant shelf contrast.
However, lighter packaging might be better when:
- Safety is a key concern – Products for children, sensitive skin formulas, or gentle cleaning supplies benefit from lighter colors that signal safety.
- You’re selling natural or organic products – While dark green can work for eco-friendly items, lighter colors often better communicate “natural” and “pure.”
- You need to show what’s inside – If seeing the actual product is important to your customers.
Real-World Success Stories
Many successful brands understand this color psychology principle:
- Luxury skincare brands often use black, navy, or dark burgundy packaging
- Professional-grade tools typically come in black or dark gray
- Performance car products frequently use black with bold accent colors
- High-end chocolates are commonly packaged in dark colors
Simple Ways to Test This for Your Business
You don’t need a massive budget to test how color affects your sales. Try these approaches:
- A/B test with a small batch – Create a limited run of your product in darker packaging and compare sales side by side.
- Online testing – Show different package colors to your social media followers or email list and ask for feedback.
- Start with a single product – Test the color theory on one product before changing your entire line.
The Bottom Line
As packaging design creative strategist Jenn David Connolly notes, “color influences consumers not only on the conscious level but also on the subconscious level,” making your packaging color choice “equally as important as choosing its ingredients.”
Darker packaging could be the simple change that boosts your product’s perceived effectiveness and value. Just remember to consider your specific product category and target audience when making this decision.
What’s your experience with packaging colors? Have you noticed differences in how customers respond to darker versus lighter packaging? Try a test run with darker packaging for one of your products – you might be surprised by the results!
Discover how dark packaging colors can make your products appear more effective and premium. Research shows customers perceive darker packages as stronger and more powerful. Learn when to use this psychology to boost your sales. Share on X“Marketing Monday” articles archive.
Note: Some links on this page are affiliate links meaning that if you click on my link and make a purchase, I will receive a small commission. It does not however affect the price you pay. Plus, it’s a great way to support me and the content I’m providing.
